The Indianapolis Colts and 2009 Fantasy Football – No Colts in the Top Two Rounds?
Monday, May 18th, 2009
I’ve been following RotoArcade’s (Yahoo) early mock draft and today I noticed something pretty shocking. Not a single Colts player was drafted in the first two rounds. Have the mighty really fallen this far? Manning, Edge, Harrison, Wayne, and Addai have been regular first and second round names over the years. At least two Colts always go in the first two rounds, right? Well, not anymore.
Peyton Manning’s reign as the number one fantasy QB officially came to an end in 2007. Tom Brady threw 50 TDs. Manning threw 20 fewer TDs and barely cracked the 4000 yard barrier. Then in 2008 he threw for exactly 4002 yards and did not break 30 TDs. Over the last four season he’s averaged about 4000 yards and just under 30 TDs. Now, these are great numbers, but not the kind of numbers owners are looking for when they bypass a stud RB or WR to take Manning in the second round. With guys like Brees, Brady, Rivers, and Warner replicating and sometimes surpassing his numbers there is no reason to reach. Now, in 2009, Manning has lost major players in his offensive coaching group. The loss won’t have a dramatic impact, but there will be an impact on this Colt’s team. Manning should be the third QB off the board at best in 2009. I would take him in the mid to late third if no stellar RB or WR choices remain.
The biggest surprise of the Yahoo Mock Draft is that Reggie Wayne fell all the way to pick four of the third round. WRs taken before him just in round three: Anquan Boldin, Roddy White, and Marques Colston. Now, when it’s all said and done, I believe Wayne will have an ADP that falls in late round 2, but Brandon Funston makes a great case for waiting on him:
“At this point in his career, Wayne’s reputation exceeds his actual value. He’s typically on the tongue of the majority when top five receivers are being contemplated, but he’s finished outside the top dozen receivers in fantasy points twice in the past four seasons and he’s only once caught double-digit touchdown passes in that span. What he’s got on his side is consistency – 1,000-plus yards and 80-plus receptions for four straight seasons – and, with Marvin Harrison’s decline and offseason departure, the mostly undivided attention of sharp-shooter Peyton Manning. He’s an extremely safe choice at this point, and that really should be spun as a positive considering the random nature of fantasy football.”
So Wayne will go in the first two rounds, but maybe he doesn’t deserve it. Manning will spread it around to Clark, Gonzalez, and the RBs. Also watch out for rookie Austin Collie in the slot. I personally have Wayne ranked 7, just behind Boldin and Smith and ahead of Colston and White, in my 2009 fantasy football WR Rankings.
The Starting Runningback for the Indianapolis Colts still has that “insta-stud” ring to it. A man in that position should be a top five fantasy beast. Unfortunately, Mr. Addai didn’t pull it off. Donald Brown could be that insta-stud in a couple of years, but right now we’re all in wait and see mode. Addai is dropping like he’s hot on draft boards across the internet since the NFL draft. He fell all the way to round 5, pick 9 on the Yahoo mock, which I think is borderline crazy. He’s still going to get first shot at starting, and he still plays on the Colts. He’s going to get plenty of opportunities to score, even if Brown wins half the carries in his rookie season. Maybe I’m too stubborn, but I’m going to draft Addai over other questionable guys like Ryan Grant, Thomas Jones, and Willie Parker. The biggest downside is that if you want both Colts RBs you’re also going to have to use a pretty early pick on Donald Brown. I would advise staying away from him in your drafts, but if he falls to the fifth round I think you have to take him. Start considering Brown in the 7th or 8th round, especially if you’ve already rostered Addai.
Lastly, but not leastly, let’s give a shoutout to Dallas Clark. Clark, not Gonzalez, could end up being the biggest beneficiary of the Marvin Harrison departure. Manning looks for him in a lot of clutch situations, and he always delivers. A TD can come his way any game, but he’s also a candidate for the 12 target, 9 catch game, which is absolute gold in the TE slot. He can put up similar numbers to the top 3 TE’s but can be had one or two rounds later. That makes him my top value TE in the draft. If you can get him in the late fifth, early sixth, by all means do so.
Here’s a link to round three of the draft. You can surf backwards or forwards from here to see the other rounds, but you have to do some searching to find the full thing. Beware – If you click Fantasy Football Mock Draft in the right menu it will take you to the 2008 fantasy draft. Come on Andy, get that fixed!
http://sports.yahoo.com/fantasy/blog/roto_arcade/post/Fantasy-Football-Mock-Draft-Round-3?urn=fantasy,159735
The guys at 


Donovan McNabb should give the Eagles a standing ovation for their off season activity on the offensive side of the ball. He said he wanted more protection and more weapons, and he got it in a big way. The Eagles signed both Jason Peters and Stacey Andrews. They will immediately step in to be the starting tackles. Peters is as good as, if not better than, the departed Tra Thomas, and is seven years younger. The Eagles also landed an elite full back in Leonard Weaver. McNabb will be working behind some of the best protection of his career in 2009.